Emancipation or workability ? : Critical versus
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this article a distinction between a pragmatic and a critical orientation of action research is made. These orientations can be considered, implicitly or explicitly, to be the main alternatives in AR today. What are the assumptions behind, and practical implications for, AR projects with different orientations? A number of themes are introduced where a tension between the two are identified and illustrated in the form of a dialogue and friendly quarrel between proponents from each side. It is argued that the two orientations suit different research contexts and cannot easily be combined. The pragmatic orientation is well suited for contexts where concerted and immediate action is needed, whereas the critical is preferable where transformative action needs to be preceded by critical thinking and reflection. In the former, power to act is a desired outcome, and in the latter, unequal and invisible power relations need to be unveiled before they can be transformed. The responsibility of the researcher, as well as the form of knowledge developed, differs between the two orientations. Action Research
منابع مشابه
Gender, Emancipation and Critical Information Systems
This paper addresses ways in which theorizing gender may be important in forming an understanding of the topic of emancipation which is central to the new critical information systems based on Habermas’s thinking. After briefly introducing current research on gender and IS and arguing that we need to look towards feminist philosophy for appropriate theory in order to understand foundational iss...
متن کاملEnlightenment and emancipation: Reflections for critical accounting research
Molisa (2011) offers a presentation of the work of Eckhart Tolle (1997, 2005) and a critique of critical and social accounting research, particularly the notion of emancipation. While taking issue with some of both Molisa (2011) and Tolle’s (1997, 2005) arguments, I contend that their conclusions have some interesting implications. The religious traditions referenced by Tolle (1997, 2005) recog...
متن کاملRethinking Emancipation in Organization Studies . In the light of Jacques Rancière ’ s Philosophy
The demand for emancipation was once something we only associated with oppressed social groups such as Women, Workers or the colonized who were seeking to escape from various forms of domination which they had long been subjected to. Today, some of the most privileged groups in our society such as middle managers and professions talk about their thirst for emancipation. They seek this precious ...
متن کاملEmancipation in decision-making in women's health care.
BACKGROUND Emancipation as a nursing concept is derived from a long-standing history of social oppression and is easily addressed by both critical social theory and feminist theory. It is the apparent concept to describe a phenomenon witnessed in nursing when caring for women in the decision-making process about health care issues. Emancipation has been recognized by expert clinical observation...
متن کامل